ON ASSIGNMENT · LEVEL 4 · REPORTER

Critic’s Cut

Learn to think like a professional reviewer.

Whether you’re reviewing a movie, game, book, meal, product, or toy, you’ll learn how to evaluate it fairly, support your opinions with evidence, and prepare your work for the iGeneration Youth Newsroom.

Start with the Critic’s Handbook

START HERE

Critic’s Handbook

New to reviewing? This beginner-friendly handbook teaches what review journalism is, how opinions become evidence-based reviews, how to remain fair, and how to prepare work for publication.

You’ll learn how to:

  • Tell the difference between a reaction and a review
  • Support opinions with specific evidence
  • Write for a real audience
  • Follow review ethics and disclosure rules
  • Edit work before publication
Open the Critic’s Handbook (PDF) →

ENTERTAINMENT

Movie Reviews

Learn how professional movie critics evaluate story, characters, performances, pacing, visuals, music, and overall impact without giving away important surprises.

You’ll learn how to:

  • Evaluate plot, acting, and dialogue
  • Analyze cinematography, music, and pacing
  • Identify themes and emotional impact
  • Consider audience and age appropriateness
  • Record a strong first-reaction video
Open Movie Review Briefing (PDF) →

GAMES

Game Reviews

Review a video, board, card, or mobile game by examining how it works, how it feels to play, and whether the experience remains interesting.

You’ll learn how to:

  • Explain rules, controls, and the learning curve
  • Evaluate challenge, fairness, and accessibility
  • Discuss graphics, sound, and technical performance
  • Consider replay value and price
  • Recommend the game to the right players
Open Game Review Briefing (PDF) →

BOOKS

Book Reviews

Examine how effectively a book develops its ideas, characters, story, style, and themes while avoiding unnecessary spoilers.

You’ll learn how to:

  • Evaluate plot, organization, or main ideas
  • Discuss characters and writing style
  • Analyze pacing, themes, and originality
  • Write a spoiler-free description
  • Recommend the book to the right readers
Open Book Review Briefing (PDF) →

FOOD

Food Reviews

Review a meal, snack, beverage, restaurant, café, or food business and help readers decide whether it is worth trying.

You’ll learn how to:

  • Describe flavor, texture, and temperature
  • Evaluate freshness, presentation, and portion size
  • Observe service, cleanliness, and atmosphere
  • Consider value for the price
  • Write vivid but fair descriptions
Open Food Review Briefing (PDF) →

PRODUCTS

Product Reviews

Test how well a product performs its intended job and help readers understand its quality, usefulness, limitations, and value.

You’ll learn how to:

  • Evaluate setup, design, and ease of use
  • Test performance and important features
  • Consider materials, durability, and safety
  • Compare usefulness with price
  • Explain who truly needs the product
Open Product Review Briefing (PDF) →

TOYS

Toy Reviews

Test a toy and explain how enjoyable, durable, safe, useful, and age-appropriate it is for children and families.

You’ll learn how to:

  • Evaluate setup and ease of play
  • Consider creativity and lasting interest
  • Test quality and durability
  • Discuss safety and age suitability
  • Decide whether the toy offers good value
Open Toy Review Briefing (PDF) →

Your Publishing Workflow

1. Learn

Read the handbook and your briefing.

2. Research

Gather facts and study professional reviews.

3. Experience

Watch, play, read, taste, test, or visit.

4. Record

Capture your first reaction on video.

5. Write

Support your opinions with evidence.

6. Publish

Submit and share your review with readers.